A New Thing In Subscribing To Comments

I happen to use the Subscribe To Comments plugin for this blog. My version basically just adds this little box at the bottom so people can check it and get notification to any post they’ve left a comment on.

It seems that’s not quite enough for most folks these days. I’m starting to notice more and more than I’ll leave a comment on a blog, and almost immediately I’ll get an email saying if I want to subscribe to comments I have to click on a link.

I have yet to click on any of these links. I know why people are doing it, or at least I think I do. In their own way, it’s to try to cut down on spam, although I’m not sure that’s quite correct. After all, it’s not like any of the blogs I’m talking about haven’t shown my comment as soon as I’ve written it, which means any spam comments would automatically go through.

Frankly, I can’t think of any other reason for people to have added this particular wrinkle to their blogs. Once again, we get into talking about making the commenting process easier for those people who leave you good comments, and telling people that if they want to see if they’re being responded to that they have to click a link in an email and then they’ll hear back from the blog owner just doesn’t seem all that friendly to me.

Of course, I could be way off base. For anyone who has this set up and feels there’s a good reason for doing it, please enlighten me. The only other thing I can think of is that someone is worried that the person leaving the comment isn’t actually that person, and I can’t think of a single time that’s happened on any of my blogs, and I mean ever.

Blogging can be interesting, can’t it?

Westport Big & Tall: Look Your Best

11 thoughts on “A New Thing In Subscribing To Comments”

    1. You know Sire, I just keep wondering if maybe it’s because you and I are older and we don’t like the extra hassles, whereas it seems the people who keep setting all this stuff up are younger.

  1. I hear you, Dennis. My problem is that I don’t write these sites down, so I end up visiting and trying it out a few times before I finally recall. That’s why I stopped going to Michael Fortin’s blog, though it took me awhile. Hated that pop-up window each time I visited.

  2. Mitch, I use the plug in too and a lot of my readers return because either I are one of the other readers leaves a comment that calls for a response. I seldom click on the box in other blogs that I visit but when I do, I just get other comments and nothing more happens. In your blog you have two of the boxes one with a permanent tick in the box and the other blank. You had mentioned in one of your earlier posts that you will sort it out, and I am still looking foward to it!
    .-= Rummuser´s last blog ..A Journey. =-.

    1. I have looked for it, but I just can’t find it, Rummuser. The thing is, on this blog, using the threaded comments plugin seems essential to give people a chance to at least receive comments. Without it, no one seems to get anything, and I can’t figure out how to turn off the one that doesn’t work.

  3. I thought Askimet was the tool to stop spam – it works well for me by routing suspect comments into a spam folder
    .-= Peter Davies´s last blog ..Does anyone have any knowledge regarding worldprofit.com? =-.

    1. Askimet is definitely the best tool on WordPress blogs for stopping spam, hands down Peter. That’s why I can’t figure out why some folks have the comments thing set up the other way.

  4. Hi Mitch,

    This sounds like the sort of process that is a part of the double opt-in process that some autoresponders require.

    Whether it is being used to confirm emails so that the blog in question can then send out further emails through an autoresponder I can’t comment on.


    1. Hi Karl,

      Now that’s a thought I hadn’t considered. If someone is on a WP blog and has Askimet, they wouldn’t need that particular feature. I’ve been wondering if it’s a way for those blog owners to see who’s serious about receiving comments back or not also. I’d rather not take that chance.

  5. Hi Mitch,
    I also once installed the same plugin but one thing that I’m uncomfortable with is that my inbox gets full whenever other people leaves a comment. 🙂
    .-= Rian´s last blog ..Smart Bro Share It Slow Connections – Your Share It Router Might be Defective =-.

    1. Rian, that wouldn’t be close to a problem if you had Mailwasher, as it lets you check your email while it’s still on the server and delete what you don’t want to download. And remember, you can unsubscribe to any post at any time.

      Course, if it’s your own blog and you’re getting lots of comments, don’t complain! lol

Comments are closed.